[CQ-Contest] Publishing complete logs i/o UBNs

[Tonno Vahk]

well, I think it is quite hypothetical that some newcomers will actually get 
mocked because of the mistakes they made and will leave contesting because 
of that...

Anyway, what we want mostly is to have TOP SCORERS UBN's and logs published. 
They would not be afraid of that, right? So let's say top 10 of each 
category or more or less depending on the activity in a specific category.

There is no public interest for newcomer's or Sunday operator's LOG and UBN 
anyway!

73
tonno
es5tv
----- Original Message ----- 
From: "Vladimir V. Sidorov" <eu1sa at belsonet.net>
To: <cq-contest at contesting.com>
Sent: 16. mai 2005. a. 10:13
Subject: [CQ-Contest] Publishing complete logs i/o UBNs


> Gents,
>
> There came up an idea to publish complete logs upon checked, etc. And this
> idea is followed by supporting votes.
>
> Let me express an opposite opinion and to explain, why.
>
> For several years I am involved into log checking in our domestic HF
> championships. Time by time, having seen quite substantial percentage of
> unconfirmed contacts, people also asks me to publish all logs upon 
> checking
> in order to analize confirmed/unconfirmed contacts AND TO AVOID POOR
> OPERATORS IN THE NEXT CONTEST!
>
> Obviously I don't support it and never publish checked logs.
>
> If such an approach is followed, soon we can get some kind of black lists
> freely distributed just like SCP files... And young operators/newcomers,
> slashed into their faces will leave the contesting world forever.
>
> Do you want it?
>
> 73,
> Vladimir EU1SA
>
> _______________________________________________
> CQ-Contest mailing list
> CQ-Contest at contesting.com
> http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest