[CQ-Contest] Xtreme Category: the sky is NOT falling

[kr2q at optimum.net]

Maybe follks just to debate this stuff.

Contesting, DXCC, whatever, is based on the presumption of entrant/applicant honesty.
Are there cheaters?  Sure.  There has always been cheaters.  If someone fakes their
way to DXCC or DXCC Honor Roll, does it diminish YOUR accomplishments?  That is your call,
but there is zero doubt that folks have cheated.  Have you given up on DXCC?

So why would you give up on Contesting?

I would hope that if you enter the Xtreme category and work "a new one," that you would,
ON YOUR OWN, realize that the QSO may not be  "valid" for DXCC, depending on "how" 
made and completed the contact.

You don't think guys have used "their buddies" antenna and receiver via telephone to work
"a new one?"  Get real.  This has happened since the days of a tin can and a waxed string.

If you feel that this new category, which has not even been run yet, and we have no idea
of how popular it will be, will destroy you enthusiasm for contesting/DXing, then it is my
opinion that you are not recognizing what has been taking place "forever."  The only thing
that has changed is that now those SDR/internet/linux guys have a legal place to play.

I think it will be "fun" to see what folks come up with...just how inventive are they?  Is this
"real" ham radio?  Who knows...that's your call.  Personally, I agree that I would not have
much enjoyment entering such a category, but then most guys dont' like "my" category of
entry either (QRP), but I have lots of fun with it and I am thankful that the category 
exists....and I bet nobody doesn't get on because of it.

Formally recognizing and promoting what already exists is NOT changing the world.

I encourage everybody to continue the discussion; I am sure not the be-all and end-all
source of knowledge (or opinion) on this (or any) topic.  It is sure interesting reading.

de Doug KR2Q