[CQ-Contest] Deleted ARRL sections

Doug Smith dougw9wi at gmail.com
Sat Nov 7 15:08:43 PST 2009


>> Czechoslovakia ceased to exist, as it split into two new countries
>> (entities).

IMHO you're comparing apples and oranges.  ARRL Sections and DXCC Entities have completely different purposes.

DXCC Entities exist for the purpose of the award.  Maintaining a list of "deleted entities" ensures that someone who went through the work of QSOing 
and QSLing the Canal Zone receives credit for that work, without implying that the Zone still exists.

ARRL Sections are for the purpose of administering the work of the League.  There is no award for the greatest number of Sections worked over time -- 
being able to present a QSL for a 1934 QSO with Southern Minnesota doesn't earn you an additional credit for the WAAS** Award.  There really is no 
need, beyond historical interest, to know what ARRL Sections existed in the past or who worked them.  It's of no value today.

To that end, I would suggest no Section is ever deleted -- it's just that Section boundaries and names change.  It's kinda like redrawing electoral 
district lines.  When Wisconsin lost a seat in the House of Representatives some years ago, that territory wasn't "deleted" -- it just ended up in 
some other Congressional District.

-- 

Doug Smith W9WI
Pleasant View, TN  EM66

** Worked All ARRL Sections.  No, to my knowledge it doesn't exist.


More information about the CQ-Contest mailing list