[CQ-Contest] RES: RES: Club/Group competition 275 km radius in CQContest (petition for change).

py5eg py5eg at iesa.com.br
Fri Apr 8 09:43:37 PDT 2011

Hi Wayne
Yes I know the reasons and BTW I belong to the same era.
I think is natural in any kind of Sports or hobbies that the rules are designed accordingly with the needs, environment and aspects of a certain time.
Having said that, we must also to consider that everything is moving ahead based upon the evolution of the technology. Our hobby must be adapted with such new ambient.
Nobody wants to have an official result of a competition one year alter the event.
When has been established 30 or more days to submit a log the access to the mail, was slow and inefficient. Paper log was the reality at that time and log checking process didn't have the access to computer software.
We should also to consider that our hobby is competing with so many other Sports and activity and is totally unacceptable to maintain rules developed for a different stage of the humankind
Especially the young generation is not prepared to be part of something where the competition rules are not compatible with the other hobbies or sports.
I understand that the old guys like me should work in the way to address the  present generation.

I must say that I have full respect for different opinions.


-----Mensagem original-----
De: Wayne Mills [mailto:n7ng at bresnan.net] 
Enviada em: sexta-feira, 8 de abril de 2011 11:55
Para: py5eg
Assunto: RE: [CQ-Contest] RES: Club/Group competition 275 km radius in CQContest (petition for change).


At least at the time -- back in the 70s -- there were definite, plausible
reasons for the limitations on club membership / contest submissions. Are
you aware of these reasons? If so, I won't bother.

I agree that there is a problem that needs to be addresses, but it is
important for those in your position to understand the reasons for these

Wayne, N7NG
Jackson Hole, WY

-----Original Message-----
From: cq-contest-bounces at contesting.com
[mailto:cq-contest-bounces at contesting.com] On Behalf Of py5eg
Sent: Friday, April 08, 2011 5:14 AM
To: Martin Monsalvo, LU5DX; Joe
Cc: cq-contest at contesting.com
Subject: [CQ-Contest] RES: Club/Group competition 275 km radius in CQContest
(petition for change).

Hi Folks

I'm contester for the last 50 years and one of the founders of Araucaria Dx
Brazil is a country with more than 8 millions Km2 with no more than a total
of 30.000 Hams and only a small portion of that active on HF.
Our GADX has now 30 years 300 members and we are proud to have members in
all 5 Continents.
I have three contest stations; one in São Paulo area, Araraquara PS2T, one
in Curitiba ZW5B and in Florianopolis PT5T, and in addition to that other
members owns around 10 large and medium size contest stations. Please take
in account that those three stations are placed in a radio of 700 Km.
The rule for 275 Km maybe could be applicable for highly ham populate
countries but it has no sense at all for a vast majority of countries around
the World.
We contest organizers should stimulate the young generation to our hobby and
well organize clubs and not create barriers.
This does not mean that small groups should not be stimulated. Yes a great
number of GADX members apply their logs for small local contest groups, and
this is nice for our hobby.
I kindly ask the friends who have a different view, to imagine how could a
contest group placed in Argentina, Brazil, Uruguay, Australia, large
countries in Africa among others, to be competitive against groups placed in
US, Europe, or other highly ham populated area.
I already made an open disclosure of my position in CQWW Advisory Committee
where I was a member for 20 years and also to the majority of the contest
organizers, and all of them, no exception agrees that something must be
done, but unfortunately no action.
It is a shame, in my opinion, that we still on most important contests,
showing no movement to change and/or develop the following aspects:

  1) This ridiculous general limitation for clubs radius.
  2) Considering the technology of today why 30 days to submit logs-
incentive to cheat?
  3) Official results in almost a year ????
  4) Why not open logs immediately after the submission period. i.e 72 hours
  5) Why not some requirements for top 5 competitors as the Russian are
doing now? - Why not the entire contest recorded for those who are playing
for top 5 or records.
  It is time for innovation and we must follow the wave.

Congratulation Marti for bringing up again this important subject for an
open discussion.

Best regards


-----Mensagem original-----
De: cq-contest-bounces at contesting.com
[mailto:cq-contest-bounces at contesting.com] Em nome de Martin Monsalvo, LU5DX
Enviada em: quinta-feira, 7 de abril de 2011 23:12
Para: Joe
Cc: cq-contest at contesting.com
Assunto: Re: [CQ-Contest] Club/Group competition 275 km radius in CQ Contest
(petition for change).

Yeah Joe pretty opposite to what we propose, but of course is your point of
With al due respect.
If you were the contest organizer you would probably loose support from a
few thousand or regular entrants and your contest would probably loose
interest and popularity.
Perhaps if you were the organizer as you say you are always on the minority
on most topics that would be your objective.
O'course we want more members in our club and that's why we work so hard to
encourage new hams to enter CQ contests and submit their logs. But not only
that, we want them to be more involved in tech stuff, operating techniques
and thus, to be able to enjoy more and more Qs during contest weekends.
Similar things are happening in Chile and Uruguay where you guys had to
struggle fo find a CQ Zone 12 or CX mult years ago and now have many
stations available from those locations, without trying to sound to proud of
ourselves (and I'm talking about several different groups), that's the
result of years of hard work, motivation, providing info and helping in
whatever we can to people that live in interior provinces, with few
resources and lots of difficulties. Even though they love the hobby, they
want to participate and they want to contribute to their club scores, even
if they had not had the chance to have been born in New England, or
Saying "hey go get more members" in certain countries means "go make more
hams" and that involves economics and other circumstances that go far beyond
your simplistic suggestions.

Don't think you need a flame suit though. The lack of perspective is
something hard to overcome and rever,  and certainly the flames won't even


Martin, LU5DX

On Thu, Apr 7, 2011 at 10:37 AM, Joe <nss at mwt.net> wrote:

> I'm probably going to be in the minority on this as  I have been on most
> other topics like this.
> But I think in exactly the opposite direction. I feel the circle is ten
> times TOO BIG right now!  I do not feel that two people over 500 miles
> apart are in the same club.
> A club is a group of people that often meet Like at a monthly meeting.
> An organization yes can have members 1000's of miles apart.  But a club
> is a "Local" thing.  A Club is something you would be willing to drive
> to a meeting once a month to actually meet the other members of the club.
> I don't know many clubs that have members driving 200+ miles to go to a
> monthly meeting.
> I'd like the circle to be actually reduced to like a 25 mile radius.
> Thats a "Club" sized circle.
> If ya want more members in your club get more in the club. simple.
> But I'll put my flame suit on now.
> Joe WB9SBD
> The Original Rolling Ball Clock
> Idle Tyme
> Idle-Tyme.com
> http://www.idle-tyme.com
> On 4/6/2011 4:16 PM, Martin Monsalvo, LU5DX wrote:
> > Hi guys.
> >
> > We started a petition to ask the organizers of CQ Contest to review the
> 275
> > Km radius rule (Club/Group) competition.
> > We have been allowed by the organizers to submit our contest scores to
> our
> > clubs/groups for eleven years now, but we really feel it is time for a
> > change.
> >
> > This rule was originally written back in 1948 when these competitions
> > started and certainly the wording took into account the situation of the
> US
> > based Clubs.
> >
> > There are countries outside USA and Europe where the territory is really
> > vast and the ham population is very little. Our members feel encouraged
> to
> > enter contests even if it is ocassionally if they are allowed to submit
> > their scores to our Club/Groups, and we really believe that being these
> > competitions world wide events, the situation of other regions needs to
> be
> > considered.
> >
> > There are several options e.g.:
> > Remove the geographic limitation completely, thus, allowing members of
> each
> > Club to submit their scores to their club, no matter if they have moved
> > temporarily or permanently.
> > Keep this geographic limitation as it is for the US and Western Europe
> > countries and remove it for the rest of the world, and so on.
> >
> > If you feel like signing the petition you can do so at:
> > http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/275km/
> >
> > Thanks in advance for getting involved.
> >
> >
> > Regards!
> >
> >
> _______________________________________________
> CQ-Contest mailing list
> CQ-Contest at contesting.com
> http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest

Martin Monsalvo, LU5DX
lu5dx at mail.ru
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest at contesting.com
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest at contesting.com

More information about the CQ-Contest mailing list