[CQ-Contest] CQ WW Rules Changes

[Joe]

This i exactly where I feel the penalty is a good thing,

Copy what is sent, and log what is sent.

Copy it wrong, and you get dinged for not being a better operator. Slow 
down and be sure you got it right, ask for repeats etc. Eventually your 
skill as an operator will improve and you will copy it correctly.

Another good reason for the penalty for busted calls is this below..

 From Steef  PA3S (PA33A)

This weekend I participated the WPX with a special call sing.
And that was a big mistake.

Because the skimmers don't know the call, they spotted me with a wrong call
more times than you can believe.
So there will be a lot of stations who logged me wrong.
Also I operate assisted, and usage the RBN to work multi's.

Bud this is also proved to be impossible.
Time and time and time, the spot was nos the station calling.
When you realize that there are plenty of opp's that don't even know CW,
there must be a million busted QSO's in the logs.
==============

That alone is a good enough reason for the penalty for busted calls,  did not get the call right? get penalized for it.

Joe WB9SBD

Sig
The Original Rolling Ball Clock
Idle Tyme
Idle-Tyme.com
http://www.idle-tyme.com
On 5/26/2013 9:39 PM, Radio K0HB wrote:
> Just carrying your argument to it's logical extreme.
>
> If incorrectly recording a call sign is a violation of the contest rules
> (you assert that it is so) then XIII of the rules state that such violation
> makes me subject to a red or yellow card or other penalty.
>
> How many cobbled Q's in a log would rise to the level of "demonstrated
> pattern of misconduct"?
> *
> *
> *XIII. ACTIONS OF THE CQ WW CC*
>
> *Violation of a contest rule makes the entrant subject to a red, a yellow
> card, a warning letter or log rejection at the discretion of the CQ WW CC
> (rule III.14 always applies).*
>
>
> On Sunday, May 26, 2013, David Gilbert wrote:
>
>> What on earth is with you??  You don't get red/yellow cards for
>> unintentional errors ... you lose points for them.  You get red/yellow
>> cards for demonstrated patterns of misconduct.
>>
>> I'm beginning to grasp the child aspect of your signature, though.
>>
>> Dave   AB7E
>>
>>
>>
>> On 5/26/2013 3:47 PM, Radio K0HB wrote:
>>
>> Wow!  There will be a lot of red and yellow cards issued to all those
>> people who copied my call incorrectly!  Or maybe not.  Maybe I sent it
>> wrong, sort of an entrapment trick like not sending the same SS check as I
>> did in 1983.
>>
>>   Sunnuvagun!
>>
>>   73, de Hans, K0HB
>> Potential Red Card Recipient for a mis-copied call sign
>>
>>
>>
>> On Sunday, May 26, 2013, David Gilbert wrote
>>
>>   From the CQWW rules:
>>> XII.2.  All sent and received exchanges are to be logged. In addition to
>>> the number exchange, the call sign sent by an entrant during a completed
>>> exchange, must be logged *as sent by the entrant*. All QSO exchanges
>>> must be logged upon QSO completion.    AB7E Note:  The words "as sent by
>>> the entrant" are in italics for emphasis in the original text.
>>>
>>> So yeah, logging an incorrect callsign or exchange ... no matter what the
>>> reason ... is indeed a contest rules violation, at least for those events.
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>> --
>> 73, de Hans, K0HB
>> "Just a boy and his radio"
>>
>>
>>