[CQ-Contest] Ohio is now West Coast - rebuttal
W0MU Mike Fatchett
w0mu at w0mu.com
Mon Feb 29 20:19:17 EST 2016
You had to go back to 1972 to find these? 40 plus years ago? I wasn't
even licensed yet but I suspect JA's played a big part. Also you just
picked W6 and left out W7 and VE7. W2PV had 10 more mults but the 6's
were able to work more zones, which is interesting.
Here are the top 25 SO HP scores from 1972
1 6G1AA SO HP ALL 4,069,764 3,825 126 351 -
2 HT0A SO HP ALL 2,884,999 3,038 109 288 -
3 FP8AA SO HP ALL 2,645,019 3,260 88 245 -
4 W6RR SO HP ALL 2,350,964 1,820 134 315 -
5 K6AHV SO HP ALL 1,849,716 1,604 131 265 -
6 W2PV SO HP ALL 1,790,019 1,411 117 324 -
7 VE7WJ SO HP ALL 1,630,240 1,712 116 252 - VE7BDJ
8 WB2SQN SO HP ALL 1,546,092 1,331 114 288 -
9 W4QBK SO HP ALL 1,370,368 1,142 119 305 -
10 VP2MAH SO HP ALL 1,346,760 2,165 64 194 -
11 W6MAR SO HP ALL 1,334,494 1,177 134 264 -
12 W3EZT SO HP ALL 1,308,067 996 126 341 -
13 W9MIJ/4 SO HP ALL 1,214,220 1,019 113 307 -
14 W4ZCY SO HP ALL 1,124,214 973 123 283 -
15 W6DGH SO HP ALL 1,101,114 1,013 129 249 -
16 W3CRE SO HP ALL 1,087,564 991 112 276 - WA3HRV
17 K1CPF/1 SO HP ALL 851,136 840 101 274 -
18 HT0V SO HP ALL 843,532 1,636 72 155 -
19 W9LVT/6 SO HP ALL 795,852 975 100 198 -
20 WA2FCA SO HP ALL 795,800 823 92 254 -
21 W4NQA SO HP ALL 745,602 721 101 262 -
22 K1CSJ/1 SO HP ALL 744,246 767 101 245 -
23 W2EHB SO HP ALL 732,918 759 94 245 -
24 K6QW SO HP ALL 724,420 871 105 185 -
25 W4UPJ SO HP ALL 698,763 834 87 212 -
Were there more serious contesters outside W1 land in those days?
Maybe. Just tossing out scores does not prove anything.
Top 25 from 1973
1 4C9AA SO HP ALL 4,125,934 3,999 121 332 -
2 K6AHV SO HP ALL 1,635,039 1,537 125 244 -
3 TI2WD SO HP ALL 1,412,894 1,963 95 206 -
4 K1LPL/3 SO HP ALL 1,195,990 1,075 106 292 -
5 K1ZND SO HP ALL 1,191,015 1,060 111 288 -
6 K1CPF SO HP ALL 1,095,032 1,049 106 260 -
7 WA1JUY SO HP ALL 1,065,996 1,006 105 266 - WA2LQZ
8 W2GXD SO HP ALL 1,048,874 931 113 284 -
9 W3CRE SO HP ALL 1,012,893 1,031 105 242 -
10 W6DGH SO HP ALL 983,016 1,070 127 201 -
11 K4VX SO HP ALL 964,366 915 109 268 -
12 K1CSJ SO HP ALL 957,852 930 108 259 -
13 WB9BPG SO HP ALL 929,124 871 119 259 -
14 K6UA SO HP ALL 895,409 940 119 218 -
15 W4UPJ SO HP ALL 851,148 931 90 234 -
16 W9MIJ/4 SO HP ALL 774,675 878 95 218 -
17 WA2DHF SO HP ALL 758,264 849 93 224 -
18 VA7WJ SO HP ALL 702,416 2,006 113 235 - VE7BDJ
19 VE3BS SO HP ALL 677,876 935 84 190 -
20 W9CTY SO HP ALL 642,690 702 98 235 -
21 WA1KID SO HP ALL 616,148 741 79 210 -
22 K6QW SO HP ALL 606,227 793 104 167 -
23 WA3GUL SO HP ALL 598,986 718 100 211 -
24 W9DUB SO HP ALL 582,900 712 95 195 -
25 W3YP SO HP ALL 559,616 625 99 230 -
Less W6's, was this just a blip in the propagation gods, more JA's to
work or more serious contesters located outside W1 land?
You can take statistics and make them tell you anything you want to see
especially when you exclude certain areas.
Since some 6's won 40 years ago I guess everything is just super? Just
move along folks, nothing to see here.
Now we move to 2010 and the landscape has changed dramatically.
1 VY2ZM SO HP ALL 9,863,138 5,832 148 486 43.7 K1ZM
2 VE2IM SO HP ALL 8,803,289 5,877 134 443 44.2 VE3DZ
3 VC3A SO HP ALL 7,447,734 5,397 137 412 42.7 VE3AT
4 K1DG SO HP ALL 6,298,860 3,801 139 471 42.3
5 YN2AA SO HP ALL 5,721,522 5,146 123 375 39.9
6 NN3W SO HP ALL 5,659,026 3,450 145 473 42.5 @N3HBX
7 VP2MDG SO HP ALL 5,394,420 4,812 120 340 35.7
8 VE3JM SO HP ALL 5,236,938 4,382 111 356 41.1
9 W2RE SO HP ALL 4,985,904 3,476 125 403 41.5
10 K4ZW SO HP ALL 4,844,712 2,981 151 448 42.6
11 W9RE SO HP ALL 4,472,940 2,843 154 433 41.9
12 K3CR SO HP ALL 3,710,133 2,541 133 404 41.4 LZ4AX
13 V48M SO HP ALL 3,534,342 3,989 102 297 31.8 W2OX
14 K3ZO SO HP ALL 3,455,135 2,428 133 382 34.7
15 VE3CX SO HP ALL 3,384,368 3,542 110 314 39.1
16 K8PO/1 SO HP ALL 3,211,092 2,565 119 348 37.4
17 OX2A SO HP ALL 3,065,904 2,951 104 319 31.6 OX3KQ
18 K5TR SO HP ALL 2,962,683 2,438 150 407 41.8
19 W0UA SO HP ALL 2,945,013 2,235 149 374 39.7
20 AA1K/3 SO HP ALL 2,878,690 2,025 136 409 38.5
21 WW1WW SO HP ALL 2,604,246 1,967 117 365 33.4 KK1KW
22 K6NA SO HP ALL 2,467,150 1,974 140 335 36.6
23 VY2TT SO HP ALL 2,401,990 2,408 98 303 22.1 K6LA
24 NR5M SO HP ALL 2,172,958 1,913 127 339 40.0
25 N2LT SO HP ALL 2,128,647 1,693 118 335 28.2
The top 6 lander or West coast station was 30th. These stats are SSB
taken from the scores database for CQ WW.
Interesting stuff.
More information about the CQ-Contest
mailing list