[CQ-Contest] WAEDC Rules error?

[Igor Sokolov]

This rule is a bit strange indeed. Some of the RA8/RA9 now are in Europe 
and some are in Asia.

It seems that this rule implies that those European RA9 can be worked 
for mult but not for points.

73, Igor UA9CDC

11.08.2018 2:48, David Siddall пишет:
> Gerry,
>
> My understanding is that the key phrase in the WAEDC rules is *"**without
> respect to their geographical location."  *The multiplier DXCC exceptions
> for European entrants are based on prefixes, not geographic location. So
> yes, VY1 would be the same mult as VE1, just as W1VE in Vermont is the same
> multiplier as W1RH in California.  VY2 would be the same as VE2.
>
> And, W0YK, K9YC, and K6XX, all in California, are three different
> mults (for Europeans) -- unless the non-6's sign /6, in which case they
> become the "6" mult.
>
> Every contest is different!
>
> 73, Dave K3ZJ
>
>
> On Thu, Aug 9, 2018 at 2:41 PM, Gerry Hull <gerry at yccc.org> wrote:
>
>>   My European friends,
>> 6 Multiplier
>>
>> For non-European stations the multiplier is the number of countries defined
>> in the WAE Country List (see below) worked per band.
>>
>> For European stations every non-European DXCC entity counts as a
>> multiplier.
>>
>> *Exception*: In the following countries up to ten numerical call areas
>> count as multipliers:
>> W, VE, VK, ZL, ZS, JA, PY and RA8/RA9 and RAØ – without respect to their
>> geographical location.
>>
>> Examples: W1, K1, KA1 and K3../1 count as W1;
>> VE1, VO1 und VY1 count as VE1;
>> JR4, 7M4 und 7K4 count as JA4;
>> ZL2 and ZL6 are two different multipliers.
>>
>> *Multiplier bonus:* Country multiplier points are "weighted" by band.
>> Multiply the number of countries worked on 3.5 MHz by four, on 7 MHz by
>> three, and on 14/21/28 MHz by two. The total multiplier is the sum of the
>> weighted multiplier points of all bands.
>>
>>
>> VE4EA, VE4JBB and I were/are going to put forth an effort from VY1AAA -- in
>> Yukon.
>>
>> Surely VY1 does not count as VE1 -- this is a typo and should be VY2 (PEI)
>> should count as VE1??
>>
>>
>> 73, Gerry VE1RM/W1VE
>>
>> Trustee, VY1AAA
>> _______________________________________________
>> CQ-Contest mailing list
>> CQ-Contest at contesting.com
>> http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
>>
> _______________________________________________
> CQ-Contest mailing list
> CQ-Contest at contesting.com
> http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest