[Mldxcc] Center?

[Alan Maenchen]

The rule says:

"A Club is defined by the ARRL competition rules."


I can give you my opinion. I was the guy who added that CQP club rule. The
reason was only to qualify "real" clubs, and not have a "team" competition
made up of various celebrities from all over the map (ie: not a real club).
The easiest way to do that was to apply ARRL club rules for the club
definition. Therefore, the geographic limitation is valid. The need to see a
club roster is not valid unless the CQP chairman asks for it. Since there is
only one club award in CQP, club size is irrelevant.

Final decision on these details must come from the present chairman: N6RNO.

73,  Alan  AD6E




On Tue, Oct 6, 2009 at 4:55 PM, SHIRLEY ROSE <rosesl at prodigy.net> wrote:

>
>
>
>
> Hi Guys,
>   For CQ contests there is great latitude as Clubs are not categorized by
> size. The Mother Lode DX/Contest Club is listed as region W6 which is the
> entire state.  The center and mileage constriction is applicable only to
> ARRL contests which by definition require us to be classified as a
> Medium Club. I am unaware of the ARRL criteria for Club competition being
> applicable to the CQP.
>
> 73 de AA6K
> Shirl
>
>
> --- On Tue, 10/6/09, Richard Hill <rehill at ix.netcom.com> wrote:
>
>
> From: Richard Hill <rehill at ix.netcom.com>
> Subject: Re: Center?
> To: k6lrn at arrl.net
> Cc: "Shirley Rose" <rosesl at prodigy.net>
> Date: Tuesday, October 6, 2009, 1:11 PM
>
>
> Hi Dick, we should be asking Shirley I suppose, as Contest VP.  The key to
> the center is whether we include Bay Area ops or Nevada ops, and Paradise.
> I may be missing key players, let me know.
>
> I thought the center was Pine Grove, but based on the map I produced and
> put in the Nugget in May, I'd guess the center should be closer to Sheldon,
> Wilton and Sloughhouse, or Cameron Park and US 50.  The problem is that we
> have members in the Bay area and near Reno/Sparks.  These are beyond the 175
> miles straight line between them (about 186 miles).  We have to make a
> decision whether to keep the bay area ops or the Nevada ops.
>
> North-south is Paradise to Twain Heart, and the long one is Paradise.
> Linking Paradise and Sunnyvale/Redwood City puts the center near Grant Line
> Road and Eagles Nest Road, but we need an accurate map to verify the
> distances since it will be tight.  Both of the suggested centers will easily
> include Twain Heart.
>
> To include K5RC means the center needs to be up around Cameron Park and US
> 50.  We have to make a choice.  One consideration might be where the biggest
> scores come from (do we get many logs from Nevada, and who else am I
> missing?).  Another might be to include the Nevada side as Mother Lode, and
> let REDXA take over the Bay Area ops.  I don't like either choice.  Better
> Ideas?
>
> I don't see any club size factor in the CQP.  They refer to "the" club
> competition, and the REDXA plaque does not distinguish club size.  However,
> I suspect we are both medium clubs with more than 10 logs or more than a 35
> mile radius, and less than 51 logs.  I suspect both span two or more
> sections and so have to go with the 175 mile radius.
>
> We do need to send in a club roster within 30 days of the contest, and
> should put it up on the web page after it is sent to NCCC.  We also need to
> verify that we don't have non-club single ops and that multi op operations
> have 50% or more club members.
>
> Rich
> NU6T
>
>
> -----Original Message-----
> >From: Dick Wilson <k6lrn at gotsky.com>
> >Sent: Oct 6, 2009 8:44 AM
> >To: REHill at ix.netcom.com
> >Subject: Center?
> >
> >I suspect REDXA will be having something to say about club competition
> >again this year challenging our membership, etc.
> >Do we have a 'center' of our area?
> >I am also asking question of Ken as one of the older members of
> >the club still participating. We 'have' to participate as a 'medium'
> >size club
> >due to the area our membership is spread. 'Local' clubs have a 35 mile
> >radius
> >which eliminates us from that class.
> >CQP rules say club competition based on ARRL rules which say members in
> >good standing, in club area, etc. All in article 8 of general rules.
> >
> >As of this AM, MLDXCC has almost 2.8 M points to REDXA's
> >approx 955K. REDXA still has scores coming from W6XU...probably 300 K
> >and N6YEU...around 150 K or so. That will put them close to 1.3 M.
> >
> >
> >73,
> >
> >Dick
>
> _______________________________________________
> Mldxcc mailing list
> Mldxcc at contesting.com
> http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/mldxcc
>