[SCCC] Additional link to explanatory message
Steve Harrison
k0xp at k0xp.com
Mon Jan 1 20:44:09 EST 2024
On 12/31/2023 4:07 PM, Wolf Leverich, WA6I wrote:
> FWIW, if we're gonna make it hard for the ARRL members to know which Board
> member is doing what, we probably ought to discard the whole geographic
> organization of the BoD and make the whole Board accountable to the entirety
> of the membership. Or something ... ;)
IIRC, the sole reason for this geographic distribution of directors is
because as amateur radio operators from all corners of the country (or
continent, since the ARRL also represents Canada, a totally-separate
country AND area), different areas encounter very different (and
sometimes conflicting with another area's concerns) facets of our
"hobby". Propagation is what is common to we all; yet, propagation is
what is most different between each area of the US (and continent, as a
whole). Weather concerns are also different and concern only certain
areas; the Pacific northwest, for example, is not the least bit affected
by a hurricane striking the east coast. Nor does a tornado hitting Lone
Pine, Colorado, have any effect upon Ft. Wayne, Indiana.
And so, way back in the olden days, Hiram Percy Maxim, himself, proposed
the concept of geographic area organization of the ARRL. I remember
reading an article back during the 50th anniversary year explaining this
reasoning.
I cannot conceive of this sort of geographic area concern being of any
interest for such national organizations as the AARP, AAA, or any
others. But note that Congress, itself, is geographically-organized,
precisely because pork for one state may well be stinky, smelly turds
for another 8-D While there are differences between the experiences
and concerns of diverse retirees of, say, New England versus the US
southeast, or midwest, or far west; and similarly, while driving habits
and techniques are somewhat different between those same areas; they are
all similar-enough as to be able to be ably represented by someone from
another altogether-different area. With the exception of Congress, the
ARRL seems to stand alone in this regard.
... And isn't it somewhat disturbing to compare the ARRL to Congress,
and declare them to be organized similarly for the same reasons.... ==8-O
Steve, K0XP
More information about the SCCC
mailing list