[TOEC] [CCF] SAC CW 2012 RESULTS PUBLISHED

[Mats Strandberg]

Håkan,

What makes you draw such conclusions in a forum for contesting?

To discuss ethics in contesting is at least according to my view important.

Maybe it is better to ask if we need rules at all - or if we should have
rules but for symbolic interpretation?

73 de someone that always be contesting, even if it means that we need to
from time to time debate issues..

RM2D, Mats



2012/11/10 sm5aqd at telia.com <sm5aqd at telia.com>

>
>  Why should we have the contest anyway, why not just close it
> down............why SAC , CQWW etc.
>  BLA BLAAAA
>
>  73 / Hawk SM5AQD
>
>
>
> ----Ursprungligt meddelande----
> Från: sm5sic at gmail.c
> Datum: 2012-11-10 05:22
> Till: "Mats Strandberg"<sm6lrr at gmail.com>
> Kopia: "CCF"<CCF at contesting.com>, "Rickard Dahlstedt"<sm6u at sk6aw.net>,
> "Jari Perkiömäki"<jpe at student.uwasa.fi>, <toec at contesting.com>
> Ärende: Re: [TOEC] [CCF] SAC CW 2012 RESULTS PUBLISHED
>
> (The msg was to big for the TOEC server, all the old comments
> deleted)
> 2012/11/10 Göran Ingemar Backman <sm5sic at gmail.com>
>
> > Dear contesters
> > The important thing is that we all agree that breaking the rules is
> not
> > acceptable. When we see a friend running 2 kW, operate outside the
> allowed
> > bandsegment, "wash" the logs after the contest, use assistance in a
> > non-assisted entry etc we should say to him that this is not OK,
> this is
> > not fair. We should all try to clean up in our community, among our
> > friends. The people in SM6 could do that in SM6 and the people in
> OH6 could
> > do that in OH6. I will do that in SM5, SM3 and OH1, because I
> operate and
> > know hams in these areas.
> > And we must be honest, SM6Z Kurt did fuck up. He did not slip below
> 3510
> > kHz for a minut or so, where he with S&P got one QSO. No, he was CQ-
> ing
> > below 3510 for more than a half hour and made 17 QSO:s during that
> time.
> > You must talk to him, Rickard. Has he problem with his gear? Then he
> rmust
> > fix his station. Did he choose to "bend" the rules "a little bit".
> Then he
> > must stop to bend the rules. The rules say in point 5 "On 3.5 MHz,
> Region 1
> > stations must not transmit below 3510 kHz on CW or above 3790 kHz on
> SSB",
> > period.
> > Next time Kurt should have CAT on his station, because then he will
> se the
> > frequencys in the log. It would also be fair, if the SAC organizer
> 2013
> > would demand Kurt to use CAT and submit a log with frequencys for
> every
> > QSO.
> > It is only a small number of stations, that do not follow the rules.
> The
> > vast majority are honest and play clean. Nontheless the cheating is
> a
> > problem also among us. Therefore we must clean up here in
> Scandinavia. Only
> > after that can we demand the same thing from other countries. And
> when we
> > win up here near aurora borealis, we can count on that it was a
> clean
> > victory.
> >  73 de SM5SIC/OH1SIC Göran
> >
> >
> _______________________________________________
> TOEC mailing list
> TOEC at contesting.com
> http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/toec
>
>
>
>