[TowerTalk] Lightning Strike
kd4e
kd4e at verizon.net
Fri Jul 7 23:15:14 EDT 2006
> I had earlier asked K4FMX for proof that his tower(s) have
> NEVER been hit by lightning but Gary is unwilling to share
> that information. Then a second question entered my mind
> "why would Gary mount a rabbit's foot on his tower in the
> first place"? Mmmmm. But that is not the reason for this
> post.
I would not reply to such a question either, it would
be a fool's errand.
You have asked him to prove a negative.
He could ask in reply that you prove that you have
never QRM'd someone without knowing it.
> My question - Is it possible to have a direct lightning
> strike on a tower and yet show no visible or hidden signs on
> the tower and/or appendage(s) or show no 'secondary' signs
> in the immediate area surrounding the tower?
> Doug/VA5DX
Direct? Improbable.
Indirect and/or surge, sure.
Theoretically.
Again, the failure to define parameters sufficiently
renders the question impossible to answer meaningfully.
Tower materials, grounding system, cables, connectors,
etc. are all variables critical to such an analysis.
I don't know about porcupines and rabbit's feet and
such but do prefer that discussions remain in the realm
of clear reasoning.
--
Thanks! & 73, doc kd4e
http://bibleseven.com
More information about the TowerTalk
mailing list