[TowerTalk] The Value of HFTA
Edward Sawyer
sawyered at earthlink.net
Mon Jan 21 14:23:04 EST 2019
Those that are firm believers in modeling should understand the purpose and
limitations of their modeling software. "Antenna Modeling software" is used
to design an antenna above a modeled ground plane below - or in free space
as desired. HFTA takes an assumed radiator and models the effect of that
radiator on a complex terrain defining the "net ground plane". You don't
use HFTA to design an antenna and you don't use a great program like EZNEC
to answer a height question above complex terrain.
One thing that HFTA does NOT do well is answer the question about stacking
from a "max gain" perspective. EZNEC will tell you the best design for
stacking yagis for max gain in a direction however HFTA will tell you what
the right height for those yagis are or if the stack is even the strongest
signal under typical approach angles.
A tool is only as good as its goal and limitations. For the right answers,
use them all.
73
Ed N1UR
More information about the TowerTalk
mailing list