Jamie,
The correct comparison should be to compare SO2R unassisted vs. SO1R
assisted.
The SO2R guys don't need spotting assistance because they have the
entire contest to S&P new stations to work. They don't need to take
their CQ machine off the air while S&Ping new stations. So SO2R
stations tend to operate unassisted.
The SO1R stations need spotting assistance because they need to S&P
stations at a faster rate. They can't afford the time to try to get
stations to id. When SO1R stations take their CQ off the air, they put
themselves at a significant disadvantage. Spotting assistance helps
SO1R stations increase their score.
I have operated both SO2R unassisted and SO1R assisted. I always do
better SO2R unassisted.
73 de Ron NØAT
----- Original Message -----
From: "Jamie Dupree NS3T" <ns3t@arrl.net>
To: <cq-contest@contesting.com>
Sent: Monday, December 18, 2006 12:50
Subject: [CQ-Contest] Get Rid of the Assisted Category
It is often said that Assisted operators will score better than their
un-assisted competitors if we had one single-op category in contesting.
So...let's look at the scores from the ARRL DX CW and SSB contests of
the past three years and see what it shows. (All these numbers were
crunched
from the ARRL contest results web site.)
What I did was take the top scores from assisted and unassisted and
simply combine them into a top 20. Pretty simple. What does it show?
Other than in HP CW, the assisted operators score higher and dominate
the top 20 combined standings.
ARRL SSB 06 HP - highest assisted finish was 14th - 5 assisted in top 20
ARRL SSB 05 HP - highest assisted finish was 6th - - 7 assisted in top
20
ARRL SSB 04 HP - highest assisted finish was 6th - 6 assisted in top 20
-
ARRL SSB 06 LP - highest assisted finish was 5th - 5 assisted in top 20
ARRL SSB 05 LP - highest assisted finish was 4th - 2 assisted in top 20
ARRL SSB 04 LP - highest assisted finish was 3rd - 2 assisted in top 20
-
ARRL CW 06 HP - highest assisted finish was 1st - 7 assisted in top 20
ARRL CW 05 HP - highest assisted finish was 1st - 6 assisted in top 20
ARRL CW 04 HP - highest assisted finish was 3rd - 7 assisted in top 20
ARRL CW 06 LP - highest assisted finish was 11th - 3 assisted in top 20
ARRL CW 05 LP - highest assisted finish was 16th - 1 assisted in top 20
ARRL CW 04 LP - highest assisted finish was 18th - 2 assisted in top 20
I like to bet on the horses - and after seeing this breakdown, I'd be
happy
to wager my money on the assisted guys in ARRL DX if there was one
single-op category.
73 Jamie NS3T
_______________________________________________
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
_______________________________________________
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
|