Tony writes:
> Obviously Rich's suppressors work. Some just can't seem to
> admit that part and want to argue the technical differences
> in what they COULD do if they chose to MODIFY or FIX the
> conventional one versus what he has done and does do with his.
Rich's suppressors work but not for the reason that he claims.
Nichrome is not a magic bullet and "low Q" or "Low Rp" is total
nonsense.
The instructions for the SB-220 (and any dual 3-500Z amplifier)
show three of his suppressors in series! Since there is not
enough room for the three suppressors between the tubes and
the RF choke, they must be installed in a "zig-zag" manner
that completely changes any resonances in the anode circuit.
The change in anode circuit resonance is more likely to be
responsible for the elimination of the parasitics than the
nichrome!
A standard method for taming "unruly" amplifiers has been
adding parasitic suppressors in the cathode (input) circuit.
In the old days that was generally two or three turns of bus
wire on the body of a 22 Ohm 2 Watt resistor. It did not have
the dissipation problems that the anode suppressors faced ...
and it was probably more effective than a second suppressor
in the anode line.
For years Rich has been making magical claims for his nichrome
suppressor and labeling any argument for which he could make
no rebuttal as barnyard waste. It is time to view the claims
for what they are - patent medicine at best and fraud at the
worst.
That his suppressors work in some cases is not in doubt .. but
anything that perturbs either the anode or input circuit of an
RF amplifier can "fix" a parasitic problem if it changes the
feedback circuit or effects the anode resonance. It is just as
likely that an unruly amplifier can be stabilized by simply
cleaning up other construction or design flaws.
What is at issue here is the intellectual dishonesty of claiming
magical powers for michrome ... and using Wes Stewart's test
results (without his permission and in violation of his copyright)
to claim the very thing that Wes disproved.
If you want to use resistance alloy in your suppressors, that's
fine. However, understand what it does and how it works. Don't
expect it to be the magic cure-all for every other design problem.
Using resistance alloy instead of fixing the circuit issues is
no different than changing the material used in a tube chimney
instead of moving the tube a sufficient distance from the wall
of the chassis. It is a band-aid that may help when other
solutions are not acceptable.
73,
... Joe, W4TV
_______________________________________________
Amps mailing list
Amps@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/amps
|