If one wanted such a thing to succeed, one would have to address your
concern.
One way would be to make most of the top prizes have a "raffle"
component. Something like "if you are the 500th contact of the #1
station, you win a prize" or if you are the 400th contact of the #2
station, you win a prize. It would probably be even better to make the #
of the contact that you would need to be random, so that contenders
could not hold back QSO #400 & #500 for their buddies.
This approach has the advantage of giving greater weight in winning to
those that make more contacts, but not to the elimination of the
possibility of winning with one QSO. Greater weight would mean more Qs
would be made in total, since participants would have an incentive to
maximize their QSO totals.
73,
Tom - N1MM
On 6/5/2015 12:01 PM, Tom Osborne wrote:
Well - even if I paid the $20, the chance of me winning the contest
AND a radio would be less than the chance I have to hit the Powerball
Jackpot.
If it was just a raffle, not connected to any contest, I'd have a lot
better chance of winning. :-) Don't they do this at hamfests? 73
Tom W7WHY
I'm not entirely sure that attaching a raffle to a radio contest
turns us
into professional radio operators any more than playing Texas Hold-em
at the
local Oddfellows Lodge turns people into Daniel Negreanu.
But... While I might disagree with Hans on the reasoning, I'm not sure I
disagree with him on the overall idea of "hurling it aside with great
force."
It is one thing to tell the 90 per cent of us who don't live on the
Atlantic
Rim "it's just for fun, compete among your peers" while the K1s and
PJ4s and
EA8s rack up win after win when the only thing at stake is fleeting
bragging
rights and an overpriced hunk of walnut. It is quite another to tell
people
"Please pay to enter my contest, but know that you'll only win one of
the
radios if you're lucky enough to be geographically blessed."
Without some kind of handicapping system to even out geographic
disparity, I
suspect the response of most hams outside the blessed zones would be
words
unsuitable for a family venue such as CQ-contest. And I suspect the
operators who did pay would, and perhaps should, be ignored by the
rest of
us.
Now, if you had a sponsor and didn't have an entry fee, then I
wouldn't see
this as any different from when the Bermuda QSO Party awarded a trip to
Bermuda to the winner.
73, kelly
ve4xt
_______________________________________________
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
_______________________________________________
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
|