As always Frank makes good points. In my case my one lowly tower is 90 feet
from the inverted-L and in fact supports the horizontal wire. It's much too
short to exhibit any resonance near topband, but I have observed an interesting
effect.
The tower also supports a pair of inverted-vee dipoles, fed in parallel, one for
40 the other for 80. With a vector analyzer I can sweep the inverted-L and
looking at the trace on a Smith chart and see a little discontinuity around 1.8
MHz that goes away if I lower the vee to the ground or terminate the shack end
of the coax. It's a really minor effect and apparent;y not even an intellectual
curiosity as I've not bothered to investigate it further. It does point out
however, that "detuning" by leaving things open circuit isn't necessarily the
way to go.
Wes N7WS
On 1/23/2019 3:45 PM, donovanf@starpower.net wrote:
Hi Todd,
In my opinion you're giving up too easily on your tall antenna.
I suggest that you focus more on evaluating its on-the-air performance ,
and not focus as intently its feed point impedance and VSWR bandwidth.
I hope you've been measuring the impedance and bandwidth
of your tall antenna with your 43 foot vertical disconnecte d from
its both its 160 meter matching components and its feed line,
otherwise it will interact very strongly with your tall antenna.
Very few of us have the opportunity to install our 160 meter
antennas a thousand feet or more from other antennas and tall
towers. As a result, the feed point impedance and other characteristics
of our antennas can't possibly match theoretical values. Nonetheless,
we enjoy our imperfect antennas with their imperfect soil conditions.
I hope you'll enjoy yours too.
73
Frank
W3LPL
_________________
Searchable Archives: http://www.contesting.com/_topband - Topband Reflector
|