Yes - that's exactly what happens with the common-mode current in a choke!
I could just as easily have wound the toroid with coax, had a
differential-mode signal flowing in the coax, and driven common-mode
current along the outside surface of the braid. The result would have
been exactly the same because the DM signal has no effect on the core flux.
Imagine a conventional 1:1 flux-coupled transformer with a 10 Ohm
resistive load connected across its secondary. We would expect to
measure a 10 Ohm resistive impedance at the primary; and if we drive a
current of 1A into the primary we would expect to dissipate 10W
somewhere. But to think that the 10W is being dissipated in the primary
wire - because we measured a resistance of 10 Ohm there - is plain
silly; it's obviously being dissipated in the secondary load. In other
words the dissipation does *not* take place in the "coupled" resistance.
A similar thing is happening with the CM choke - we measure a resistive
component in the winding impedance because of the properties of the
ferrite. If we pass current into that winding, the power is primarily
dissipated in the physical component which generated the "coupled"
resistance; that's the ferrite - not the wire forming the winding!
Anyone who has had a core overheat, or even shatter, will know it was
because of high flux levels causing heat generation within the ferrite,
*not* because of dissipation in the coax braid and subsequent heat
transfer to the core. If it were the latter, we could simply provide a
good thermal barrier between the coax and the core and never have to
worry about core dissipation again!
Steve G3TXQ
On 12/02/2015 17:48, Roger (K8RI) on TT wrote:
Sounds more like you inductively coupled the RF to the cores using
them as a load, rather than as an in line chole
73
Roger (K8RI)
_______________________________________________
_______________________________________________
TowerTalk mailing list
TowerTalk@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/towertalk
|