All these weather monitors (the ones in this price range, anyway) have
rotating anemometer cups and rotating wind vanes (more expensive
systems can use ultrasonics for these measurements) and thus have moving
parts. Those parts need bearings and most are "shielded" spherical ball
bearings that are continuously outside and exposed to weather
conditions. "Sealed" ball bearings are available but have rubber seals
that drag on the ball races and would load the cups or vanes of the
weather sensors. Thus, you can expect to have lifetime issues with these
bearings.
So, an issue is how easy it is to service these parts. I can speak only
for Davis Instruments Vantage Pro 2 systems now. Davis has an *exchange*
program that ships you a replacement anemometer/wind vane sensor-set to
install and then ship back the old sensors. I have done that once in
about 9 years due to some light drag on the wind vane; I never had any
difficulty with the anemometer bearing (yet).
Outdoor radiation shields for the temperature and humidity sensors can
be static or aspirated, and fan aspirated radiation shields can be
daylight only or 24-hour (with a rechargeable battery of some kind). In
all cases, air currents flow through the radiation shield and bring
debris that must be cleaned out occasionally. I clean mine every 18 to
24 months by complete disassembly. In my 24-hour aspirated radiation
shield, an unusual dc fan is used, and it has no markings to indicate
operating voltage. Overnight, it operates on about 2.4 volts from two
NiCd "C" cells but it gets higher voltage during the day from a separate
solar cell that powers only that aspiration fan. I replaced that fan
once when I found it ran during the day but not at night when on the
NiCd battery. The fan is easy to replace when the radiation shield is
disassembled for cleaning and the replacement already has the required
connector installed. Not cheap, however.
Wired weather monitors will have long wires that simply act as antennas
in a strong local RF field. Shielding and ferrite chokes can help but
local high power ham stations may still be a problem. I have not had a
wired system in about 10 years and I don't now remember if there were
any RFI issues with the old Davis Instruments "Weather Monitor" model
system. My Davis Vantage Pro 2 wireless system, which uses
frequency-hopping diversity, has always performed flawlessly for me.
One advantage to using Davis Instruments weather monitors is that phone
technical support (and excellent, knowledgeable support it is!) is
immediately available at no cost beyond the phone call.
I won't argue against using a wired weather monitor. Each of us has to
consider many factors when selecting such high-tech things! Cost is one
issue but so is reliability and ease of service. The convenience of
wireless comms between the display console or computer and the sensor
suite is significant. And, with wireless, I can have multiple display
consoles around the house.
I frankly don't know if a 900 MHz wireless spread spectrum wireless
weather system will affect weak-signal reception in that same band. I am
confident it would not affect any other band.
However, I would not want to put a weather monitor sensor suite up on a
ham tower; I expect the tower itself and the beam antennas above would
affect measurements of wind and rain. I have my Davis sensor suite about
6 feet above the peak of my house roof and in the clear, in an area that
is easy to access. National Weather Service standards for location of
weather sensors would have them only in clear, grassy fields; in
Southern California typical residences, that is simply not possible so
some trade-off is necessary.
Is all this weather monitoring really necessary? Surely not! But, it is
interesting and can provide useful data. Many will say that Los Angeles
does not have "weather." I agree we don't receive much rain! I might get
8 inches in moderately wet year. But rain here often comes in brief,
heavy rainfalls so measuring those is interesting. I find I look often
at the weather monitor solar radiation sensor and compare its daily
curve shape to that of my home photovoltaic solar system; curiously,
they are not always the same! Unexplained dips and peaks happen and are
often inconsistent between the two systems. Makes me wonder if there are
pterodactyls flying about...
Best wishes,
Larry McDavid W6FUB
Anaheim, California (SE of Los Angeles, near Disneyland)
On 9/19/2022 8:57 PM, Kim Elmore wrote:
As a research meteorologist, this topic is nearvand dear. I had a Peet Bros. station for some
time and truly liked it. It has in particular a heated rain gauge. But, critters kept chewing
on wires, so I chose to replace it with a Davis Vantage Vue. It’s been pretty good
over the past 10 - 15 y. Be had to replace the anemometer unit twice due to bearing failures.
At the 10 m level on my tower, It isn’t bothered by 1500 W on any HF band and is RF
silent. The supercapacitor on mine became leaky enough that it started eating the lithium 123
cells used to keep it going at night after the supercapacitor has been discharged. The
supercapacitor is potted and so not serviceable. I decided to replace the lithium cell with
two D cells at the base of my tower and have had no further issues.
Colleagues like the Ambient Weather systems.
Kim N5OP
...
_______________________________________________
_______________________________________________
TowerTalk mailing list
TowerTalk@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/towertalk
|