[CQ-Contest] Convergence and Change
k3bu at optimum.net
Thu May 26 17:51:28 EDT 2016
Sooo, your car is the "assistant", so is washing machine, telephone,
computer, software, pencil, keyer?
Aren't we looking for definition who is assisting by gathering call/freq
outside you and your shack???
Another PERSON or Gadget outside your station?
There is difference if you use your station and gadgets for operating -
FINDING Call/Freq vs. SOMEONE ELSE via whatever.
I hope you realize that is harder to run skimmer at your own QTH with
constant CQing, vs. streaming river of calls from world-wide skimmers,
The big question is who is doing the hunting, you, me, or bunch of other
assistant hunters holding the bear for you. Your gun, rifle, cannon,
binoculars are your tools, not some assistant feeding you dead bears.
73 Yuri, K3BU.us
On Thu, May 26, 2016 at 01:55 PM, Mark Bailey wrote:
> Hi Yuri:
> You are proposing a significant rule change. Some of us believe that
> software within the station, providing the same information as the
> packet cluster (other operators and/or remote software) should
> continue to be excluded in single operator categories.
> Mark, KD4D
> On May 26, 2016 11:38:27 AM EDT, Yuri Blanarovich wrote:
>> Why is it so hard to accept and use sensible definitions of SO and
>> SO - Single Operator - station operated by single, one, operator
>> without "ASSISTANCE" by SOMEONE ELSE via any means - be in the shack,
>> over internet, phone, ESP, whatever....
>> That means NOT someone/something else outside of own shack
>> is gathering
>> info on call, frequency, etc. and communicating to Single Operator.
>> Technology in one's own shack is OK, own Skimmer at the QTH is OK.
>> Remote, outside of own QTH "suppliers of call/freq", persons or
>> are assistance by someone else - NOT OK!
>> SAO - Single Operator Assisted - station operated by single, one,
>> operator with ASSISTANCE by Someone/Something Else outside of own
>> shack, via any means, providing Call/Frequency info.
>> Normal people, SO, would do hunting on their own, with own rifle,
>> find the bear and "nail" him. Feels good!
>> "Assisted" people SAO would have army of hunters, finding the bear,
>> kill him and then yell: "come, here is the bear, kill him!" Click,
>> But Hams have a problem figuring what the ASSISTANCE is. Huge
>> discussions about - is the pencil, keyer, computer, etc. assistant?
>> Personally, I would like to see the "assistance" by Internet go away
>> be restricted to use. Just like DXing was ruined by nets, list,
>> contesting is being poisoned by Internet spoon feeding Call/Freq.
>> Instead of preserving pure hunting aspect, we get crazy pileups,
>> frequency hogging, unsportsman like behavior, hunting dead bears.
>> Don't get me started on "rentastations" - hey, its me, in someone
>> else's skin!
>> Have fun, whatever is left of it!
>> 73 Yuri, K3BU.us
>> da place for conventions, weddings, concerts,...
>> On Tue, May 17, 2016 at 10:27 PM, Jack Haverty wrote:
>>> So, I'd like to see a split of assisted versus unassisted based on
>>> those observations, with the following basic definitions:
>>> Unassisted - a station using technology, of any kind, to communicate
>>> using only ham radio waves. All communication across the station
>>> boundary (building, 100-meter circle, whatever) must be performed
>>> using ham radio. Within the station boundary, other forms of
>>> communication may be used.
>>> Assisted - a station using technology, of any kind, to communicate
>>> only using radio waves, but also using other forms of communications
>>> across the station boundary for whatever purpose the operator
>>> All contact exchanges (whatever that means) must however be
>>> accomplished only by ham radio communications.
>>> In other words, Unassisted means you use only ham radio; assisted
>>> means you may use other forms of communications as well.
>>> /Jack de K3FIV
>> CQ-Contest mailing list
>> CQ-Contest at contesting.com
> Sent from my Android device with K-9 Mail. Please excuse my brevity.
> CQ-Contest mailing list
> CQ-Contest at contesting.com
More information about the CQ-Contest