[TenTec] Radial Research

[Richards]

Cool.     Just think what he could do with a REAL antenna !!     ;-)

But seriously, folks:

You advance an odd sort of argument.   Apparently, you consider it more 
admirable to enter a contest and fight tooth and nail for every contact, 
knowing beforehand the entire enterprise is doomed because the operator 
has selected a particularly, undersized, puny antenna.

Now I don't criticize the guy for doing his best with what he has... 
certainly he shows a lot of determination... but I don't t accept the 
tacit premise it is somehow more admirable to participate in a contest 
with a lousy antenna - at least not without knowing why he cannot have 
better.

Your story suggests the operator chose to enter the contest contest with 
a severely limited antenna, suggesting it is somehow more manly or 
admirable to contest with a crappy antenna.    But, without knowing 
more,  I regard that as a self-inflicted wound - like taking a rubber 
knife to a gun fight.   Custer stood tall in the saddle, but he is 
hardly to be admired.   In contrast, I more admire the operators who 
look to improve their lot.

This premise sorta like claiming it is more admirable to fight one's way 
through a contest working QRP and a wire antenna tossed over a tree - 
that this is somehow more manly than using 100 watts and a better 
antenna.    I do not accept the premise that he is more courageous 
because he chose to compete with such a lousy antenna.   If you tell us 
that is the very best he can do... that will be another story... but 
that is not how it is being presented.   The argument seems to be he is 
an inspiration because he chose to compete with a seriously crippled 
antenna.  I like his spunk... but hardly think he is more admirable 
because of his antenna selection.  You sure he could not have installed 
ANYTHING ELSE as a better antenna?

As for mamby pamby whiners, I don't know who you are referring to.

I do not recall anybody doing that here -- Instead, what I have 
witnessed are several fellers discussing how to improve their lot, and 
how to wring the most out of various antenna designs (e.g., more radials 
may improve vertical antenna performance), which I regard as exemplary 
of the good old ham tradition of experimenting and improving one's station.

Be assured,  I am NOT criticizing the operator in any way... I admire 
him for giving it his best shot.   Nevertheless, I think he MIGHT have a 
LOT BETTER SHOT if he installed a better antenna system.   One must do 
with what one has,  but it is misplaced to suggest anyone else is a 
sissy because he looks to improve his station.

Maybe I misunderstand your position, but that is... er... um...

Just MY take, anyway.    Happy Trails and good DX to ya  !!

=======================  K8JHR  ==========================


On 5/20/2012 12:48 AM, Don Jones wrote:
> My club has a new ham who has been a absolute inspiration. This guy is running 100W into a ground mounted Screw Driver Vertical with a dozen 10ft radials. He has gotten bite by the contest bug and this past season he fought tooth and nail, clawed his way to working 42 countries and making about 130 contacts in the ARRL DX SSB context. Glad he said hell with it I am going to have fun and I do not care how hard the fight is.
> In the mean time I hear these mamby panby cry babies saying I don't have enough radials - I don't have enough power - My antenna is not big enough - blaaa blaaa blaaa.
> This new guy has earned the right to say, "shut up and ham it up!"
> CQ DX de Don KO7i
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> TenTec mailing list
> TenTec at contesting.com
> http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/tentec
>