Topband: Band plan violations

[Dave Henderson]

Don et all

Your sentiment about disqualifying people who refuse to honor the band 
plans is the correct one. The problem is "proving" that it was Station 
W#XYZ and not someone bootlegging his call just to get him disqualified. As 
someone who has had his call bootlegged on occasion it is very 
disconcerting to sit there and listen to your call being sent and the 
station being worked while you do nothing....

Your sentiment about the contest sponsor not taking a clearer and stronger 
position about the band plan is also well placed. CQ are you listening?

  I basically did the same thing Tom did and I have a list of over 40 calls 
who I heard below 1843 who I refused to work then or later once they moved 
up,  Only a hand of full of DX figured it out on the first night which was 
disappointing considering all the discussion here on the reflector over the 
past 6 months. Thanks to OT2T who finally started listening up. 
Unfortunately many of the better ops could not resist calling the DX below 
1843, I was so disgusted I didn't even bother to work the contest the 
second night.

Dave
NR1DX
PS: I will be glad to provide a copy of my list of stations heard "out of 
band plan" to any one who requests it on a private email basis, I will not 
post it here on the reflector.