[UK-CONTEST] RSGB Contest Committee

[g3ydy]

Re Contest Rules WRT to VHF contests in particular

relating to power I fully agree that the rules regarding power and antennas
need very careful consideration and revising. There is the current situation
where a station with two Yagi's and 50 watts has to be in the same section
as a 400W single or multiple yagi.

Has ERP been forgotten about? Or is it that this cannot be mentioned due to
dumming down.

-----Original Message-----
From: uk-contest-bounces at contesting.com
[mailto:uk-contest-bounces at contesting.com]On Behalf Of Mike Farmer
Sent: 21 June 2010 21:13
To: UK-Contest; Chairman, RSGB Contest Committee
Subject: Re: [UK-CONTEST] RSGB Contest Committee


My penny worth


1.8 MHz CW CONTESTS

Whist fiddleing with the rules for the 160m CW contest why not introduce an
SSB 160m Contest?

AFS SUPER-LEAGUE

My cynical view suggests that all this will do is introduce louder (and
probably) wider signals on the bands. I do not believe we need it.

CONTEST RULES

Remove the rediculus rule which places 100w stations with beams in a
catergory where they compeate against 400w (or 400w plus) stations.   We are
suposed to improve our stations and we used to accept the principle that the
minimum amount of power to make the QSO was the correct amount of power,
therefore antenna improvement was a good way forward the RSGB now activly
discriminates against operators who do this.

ROPOCO CONTESTS

Good idea to introduce an SSB section - you may end up actually encouraging
some newcomers.


HF CHAMPIONSHIP

I hope this will result in a better balance across the many contesting modes
currently I belive this championship is loaded towards the CW freaks.  I
have said before that it is possible to win the HF Championship using only
CW and not possible to win it using only SSB (or any other mode). To make it
a true championship an entry should be the highest positions by a station
using a personal call (ie no Contest calls allowed) in 2 CW contests plus 2
SSB contests plus 1 RTTY contest plus 1 other data mode contest


REAL-TIME SCORING

I would like to know what the RSGB Contest Committee currenty see as the
benifits of real time scoring.  My current view is that it would be a waste
of effort unless it become mandatory for stations submitting an enter to
take part.


Mike
G3VAO

_______________________________________________
UK-Contest mailing list
UK-Contest at contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/uk-contest