[Top] [All Lists]

Re: [CQ-Contest] SS SSB And Your Callsign In The Exchange

To: "Paul O'Kane" <pokane@ei5di.com>, "CQ-Contest" <CQ-Contest@contesting.com>
Subject: Re: [CQ-Contest] SS SSB And Your Callsign In The Exchange
From: "K0HB" <kzerohb@gmail.com>
Reply-to: K0HB <K0HB@ARRL.ORG>
Date: Sat, 15 Nov 2008 02:56:37 -0000
List-post: <cq-contest@contesting.com">mailto:cq-contest@contesting.com>

My comments are intermingled with yours below.

> My question is - why MUST the call be part of the exchange
> when it's already "exchanged" as part of the QSO initiation
> process?  The second call exchange serves little or no useful
> purpose - it is effectively a handicap imposed on all QSOs.

Sweepstakes was originally a contest among traffic handlers, and the contest 
exchange mimics the old NTS traffic handlers message header.  In that 
header, the "callsign" was the callsign of the originating station (which 
might or might not be YOUR station).

> Of course, exchanging the call twice may help to reduce
> logging errors.  This would apply equally to the QSO Number,
> Precedence, Check and Section - but there is no requirement
> to repeat those.

It also eliminates waiting 10 or 15 minutes to figure out who the jerk is 
that doesn't ID his station, as often happens in other contests. ;-)

> If "own call" is indeed an essential part of the standard
> exchange of information, why then is it omitted from the
> exchange fields in the Cabrillo specification for SS QSOs?

It ISN'T omitted in the CABRILLO spec.  Below is a snippet from an SS 

QSO: 14076 CW 2008-11-02 1911 K0HB        700 M 62  MN W2LHL       226 A 52 
QSO: 14076 CW 2008-11-02 1913 K0HB        701 M 62  MN NI6T        293 U 56 
QSO: 21031 CW 2008-11-02 1919 K0HB        702 M 62  MN KH7Y        557 A 56 
QSO: 14076 CW 2008-11-02 1926 K0HB        703 M 62  MN K1ZZI       668 U 62 
QSO: 14076 CW 2008-11-02 1927 K0HB        704 M 62  MN VY1EI       232 B 06 
QSO: 14076 CW 2008-11-02 1928 K0HB        705 M 62  MN N5KEV        94 A 03 
QSO: 14076 CW 2008-11-02 1929 K0HB        706 M 62  MN W5EB         45 A 64 

I understand you Irish have a SweepStakes too, but the exchange seems to 
entail sums of cash.

73, de Hans, K0HB


CQ-Contest mailing list

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>