Scott,
Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't there more to this story than your
telling?
That is, the use MM0LID for many years, which was a bogus call, and not
having HF privileges?
Barry W2UP
On 1/27/2018 11:54 AM, scottmcleman36@gmail.com wrote:
Jim,
As far as I am aware this rule is for the top 5 in all SOAB categories. I
really cant say about the single band efforts.
This is really disheartening to be subject to this.
I would however accept and understand the ruling if I had placed top of the
category in the world or even top EU and be subject to receiving a plaque. But
that is not the case.
When the Raw scores were published was not in the top 5... So by my reckoning
there is others who should have placed above me been reclassified or DQ
altogether too.
I thought the general idea was to encourage people to contest.
This kind of ruling really puts people off.
Im sure someone who would just decide to enter for fun and then on the off
chance place in the top 5. Whats the chances of them actually recording their
audio? Very little I say.
Then they get removed from the results. Poor show.. This would really put them
off entering again.
Now with that being said, with my result being removed. Has the person next in the standing got a
recording? If not are they removed too and then repeating further down the list of standings? How many will
actually get removed and reclassified to an “Administrative Checklog” due to not feeling the
need to record audio . As the rule state “If Competing for a TOP 5 Place”
I have appealed the decision, but I don’t expect it to change.
Guess its just a reminder to start recording everything, even f you don’t plan
on being in the top 5, you might end up there!
73, Scott
MM3AWD
From: Jim Stahl
Sent: 27 January 2018 18:44
To: scottmcleman36@gmail.com
Cc: cq-contest@contesting.com
Subject: Re: [CQ-Contest] CQWW SSB 2017 Effective DQ
I would have thought this applied only to the top five overall scores, not top
scores in individual categories. With the possible exception of the All Band
Assisted/Non-Assisted and perhaps All Band Low Power. With QRP, there is very
little running to be done, especially on SSB, so a very high percentage of QSOs
will appear in other logs, subject to verification by log cross checking.
Does the recording rule also apply to the top five entrants in the 3.7 MHz QRP
Assisted Category? (A listed category in the 2016 SSB Top Scores, as published
in the April 2017 CQ)
73 - Jim K8MR
On Jan 27, 2018, at 10:55 AM, <scottmcleman36@gmail.com>
<scottmcleman36@gmail.com> wrote:
So i received an email from the CQWW Contest Committee. I will be reclassified to an
"Administrative Checklog" for the 2017 CQWW SSB Contest.
This is because i am placing in the top 5 of the QRP Category and i did not
make an audio recording of the contest.
This is ridiculous! i will not be listed in the results. Effectively being
disqualified without the actual DQ label!
I did not record my audio because
A) I did not expect to place highly
B) I did not win or qualify for a plaque
C) I compete for fun
Yes i could have recorded my audio, but i was not expecting to place highly. I
went to a lot of effort to be on the air!
To end up with nothing to show for it in the results is ridiculous.
I would have accepted this if i had placed 1st in the category or had placed
high enough to win a plaque. but not for being in the top 5.
Or even being reclassified into another category. Not to be effectively
disqualified.
I think this rule really needs to be looked at!
Is this what a contester can expect in the future? to be removed from results,
if they unexpectedly place in the top 5!?
This really makes me not want to participate in what is classed as the biggest
contest of the calendar.
Below is the email i received from the committee.
Dear MM3AWD,
We previously requested that you submit an audio recording of yoru CQWW SSB
2017 contest operation, as required in the CQWW Rules.
CQWW Rules (XII.C. Audio Recordings):
“Audio Recordings: Any single operator entrant (see V.A.1) competing for a top five finish at the (a)
World, (b) Continent, or (c) USA levels, including Classic Overlay, must record the transmitted and received audio
as heard by the operator for the duration of the contest operation. The recording must be in a common format
(e.g., mp3) and should include the audio to each ear as a separate channel. The recording must be a continuous
recording (not a recording of individual QSOs). Time “off the air” (when not transmitting or
receiving) does not have to recorded. The recording may be requested by the Committee within 120 days after the
log deadline to help adjudicate the log. The recording files must be provided by the entrant within 5 days of the
request. If no recording is made available, the Committee may reclassify to an appropriate category, reclassify to
Administrative Check Log, or disqualify the entry…”
Because you did not submit the required audio recording, your entry has been
reclassified to the Administrative Check Log category.
Your score will not be listed in the results. Your call sign will be listed as
an Administrative Check Log.
We welcome you to participate in the CQWW contests in 2018 and sincerely hope
to see you then.
73’s
Bob, W5OV; Doug, KR2Q; Scott, W4PA
Co-Directors
CQWW Contest Committee
73, Scott
MM3AWD
_______________________________________________
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
_______________________________________________
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
_______________________________________________
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
|