My vote is: If it increases the fun, do it.
While I understand the logic of the argument "it reduces the number of
available stations to work", that argument relies on the assumption that
participants in a M/MD operation would have been on the air at least as much as
discrete stations than they are as contributors to their M/MD efforts.
I am skeptical of that assumption.
Personally, I know that my butt-in-chair time is increased when "contributing
to club score" is my objective. I assume that at least some M/MD operators
would have an analogous sentiment in such operations. And if I'm not mistaken,
in the case of WW1X operators were active when they might not otherwise have
been.
It might be interesting after a post-pandemic contest that permits M/MD to
survey participants at such operations and/or compare their participation
levels to prior runnings of that contests. That might shed more objective
insight as to whether the class increases or decreases the aggregate Q total
(and thus whether fun is increased or decreased).
--
Michael Adams | mda@n1en.org
_______________________________________________
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
|